Geographic Limitation

Non-compete agreements frequently include a geographical limitation by necessity. A restrictive covenant without a geographic limitation will almost never be enforceable. Often this geographic limitation is expressed by a radius around the company’s headquarters. Other times the geographic limitation is defined by listing specific cities or states in which the employer does business. A geographic limitation will only be enforceable if it is reasonable. What is reasonable depends largely on facts unique to each employer such as the goods or services provided, the size of the business, the amount of business the employer does in the restricted area, and the type and number of customers located within the restricted area.

In 2011, the Illinois Supreme Court considered the question of whether a geographic limitation in a restrictive covenant was reasonable. In Reliable Fire Equipment Company v. Arredondo, 2011 IL 111871, the geographic limitation of the non-compete agreement included all of Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin. The lower courts had determined that the geographic limitation was not reasonable. The Illinois Supreme Court held, however, that the large geographic limitation was reasonable to protect the employer’s legitimate business interests.

As stated previously, the reasonableness of a geographic limitation turns largely on the unique facts of each case. In the case of Callahan v. L.G. Balfour, 534 N.E.2d 565 (Ill.App. 1989), for instance, an Illinois appellate court found that a geographic limitation of Chicago and seven surrounding counties in a covenant not to compete was too large to be reasonable. The court stressed that such a restriction imposed an undue hardship on the employee who had thirty years in the industry and would have to move far away in order to find a job in the same industry and still comply with the non-compete agreement.

There is no one-size-fits-all geographic limitation and each state has its own standards for determining what limitation is reasonable. It is crucial to have an attorney familiar with the standards of your local court review a prospective or existing restrictive covenant for enforceability.

This is where the attorneys at DiTommaso can help. Our attorneys have decades of experience negotiating and litigating non-compete agreements and other restrictive covenants. Conveniently located in Chicago and Oak Brook, IL, we have a wealth of knowledge regarding the various standards applied by the courts in DuPage, Cook, and the surrounding counties along with the constant changes to those standards. Whether you are looking to negotiate a non-compete agreement or are being accused of violating one, a skilled attorney is needed. You can contact us online today or call us at 630-333-0000.

Client Reviews

Jim DiTommaso and his staff were remarkably helpful and performed above and beyond our expectations when dealing with potential consumer fraud on our behalf. My husband and I first discussed our case with Jim during a phone consultation. He and his staff did some preliminary research before agreeing...

Katrina L.

A great firm with attorneys who truly fight for their clients. The Firm was on the case at all hours and made my interests a priority. All stars that I would have represent me time and again. Great job guys!

Mark Z.

Never having the need to consult a law firm before to defend ourselves in a small business/family dispute it was VERY overwhelming. Not knowing where to go or who to call, we took the advice of our daughter who did the internet research (Because that's what young adults do these days) I was hesitant...

Gina G.

Vincent DiTommaso represented me in a complicated medical/business lawsuit. Vince and his team are not only personable and very professional, they are extremely competent litigators. I got to know Vince and his team very well over the 3 years of litigation in my case. The team is very sharp and...

Zahid A.

I called this law firm about a problem I had with my business partner. Vince DiTommaso got back to me right away and arranged to meet with me. The firm answered all my questions and came up with a great plan. They ultimately filed suit and were able to successfully negotiate a settlement for me. I...

Diahn H.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Years of Experience
  3. 3 Track Record of Success
Fill out the contact form or call us at 630-333-0000 to schedule your free consultation.

We Accept the Following Credit Cards: